Posts by Idhril

Yep totally 💯

Yeah I am offended you got me. I always watch other ppl xD and ask them how to play classes

I am not. I think this is just not necessary.

Beside this:

"What about adding no gear durability loss with the aura of reviving?"-Lutine

Is a very good idea since this upgrade is quite "expensive".

Why this stupid idea is needed or should be ...

Warrior warlock has abit low substain in single target and is very good in bigpulls with buffs and do more than other dps in this situations but in my pov it's needed because otherwise it's will not keep up with other dps in orkham. Because they earn much more beside bigpulls with cds.

So for me the latest changes work out quite well

Full burst single target is also good.

So for me no changes needed even a buff or a nerf. And keep in mind you need/should use another rune which you have to craft and build and roll another weapon.

Badge of the worldwide fame [240737] in Happy Hour please

Kind regard idhril

If the developers to consider to make nostalgia instances harder keep In mind that not everyone is playing on this level we do. So I prefer a buffed modus for this instances which you can activate with one NPC inside for example. Dropping some amount of gold would be insane.

Greetings

Warden Mage and Warden Bard is also okay.

But need some small love

Bard Scout what I saw was really strong in single target(1week ago) maybe abit to strong but idk how it perform in orkham but in FA HM it performed very op. Burst and substain was insane.

But I have something the class was fine in gameplay and fun like it was before the patches single bleed on one target I suggest to rework it completely or reroll it to old warrior bleed gameplay if you think bleed was way to strong. Just adjust the multiplier

100%agree

I suggest to change sonic chop from warden bard to dynamic cd like piercing arrow min: 1.5 or 2 sec max 3sec cd depending on mainhandweapon atk speed

/script local _,SysTitle,_ = GetATF_Title(1); local boss = UnitSex("target") > 2; local _,SysTitle2,_ = GetATF_Title(2); local _,Titel = GetCurrentTitle(); if SysTitle ~= "Festmahl Zubereiter" and not boss then SetATF_Title(532149); end; if SysTitle ~= "Leuchtender Pfadfinder" and boss then SetATF_Title(532134); end; if Titel ~= "Zhargos' Bezwinger" then

SetTitleRequest(532153); end; here for all no script players just put you're kitty execute behind this

Hey

this version containes all 8 actionbars with changed Actionbarskin

Have Fun !

Quote from Madman

Quote

My personal anecdote:

Reading the initial patch notes I was very excited. Bought 2h Sword, tested Warrior/Warlock alot in Itnal, kept rolling for good stat in weapon but needed 1-2 more days to try it myself in Orkham. I even sold my Katana since if I have a 2h Sword, I can Play Warrior/Scout with that and use Spear for Bleed if needed.

Now I read, that the skill has been disabled. Awesome, Crystals wasted, Katana sold and I cannot even try this class once myself to confirm your experience.

It's not like I tried it with Katana or another weapon, I had to make a new 2h sword too, roll until I got max roll stat then use tiers and get new runes to test it.
I tested in many runs yesterday with different raid setups vs Burst classes (champ, w/s,...) vs Dot classes (w/b, r/d ,r/w), with and without Dot rune and robot. The outcome was the same (R/D being op too could compete with my dots but that was it). I was also competing with players with full Orkham accessories and lower sets while I have none.

However, I do agree that removing 2h sword requirement + removing aoe dot will kill this class along with the investment some players made to play around with it.

My suggestion for w/wl is the following:
Keep "Spirit Wound" dot removed from Spirit Blade Storm. Make Spirit Cracking blow (498780) require 2h Sword and allow it to spread the dot to monsters that are getting hit by your Spirit Blade Storm. This would mean you can only apply your dot every 6s (on skill use) and you have to time both skills together if you want the aoe dot. The flat amount of the dot can remain the same.

Display More

Idk what happen in youre runs but for me it feels like that other players as dps don't perform as good as they can. Remember this warden/bard scruti from you're guild. I don't remember from who or when exactly it was but It wasn't never over perform and definitely not stronger than warrior Mage or leather metas. But I saw here some topscruit screenshots pls compare with equal gear and knowledge players

Otherwise things get nerfed who don't need it

I can agree with blackkid.

Quote from Madman

Quote

Warrior

• Changed Slash bleed to include target’s physical defense into its calculation.

IMHO this change officially killed Spear (a weapon specialized in bleed. You might as well delete it from the game). There is no motive anymore to sacrifice 1 gcd to apply your (single target) bleed when all your other skills hit harder.


Warrior/scout was not heavily impacted because its single target burst is still very good without bleeding and because it can wear 2 corrupted weapons. However, other warriors will fall off a lot in single target sustain/burst.
Some warriors rely on bleed to keep up in aoe too by rotating slash on multiple targets due to bad aoe sustain against other classes (while some other classes can apply aoe dots with one skill) There are other ways to balance Slash bleed other than what's in patch notes atm.

- If boss/mobs dot reduction is not working as intended, fix it.
- If Bleed is doing too much dmg, reduce the dmg multiplier from the formula instead of making Bleed act like a normal skill.

Display More

I 100% agree. + Bleed was a way to compete with other classes.

Is it not possible to rotate the weapon model of his sword when weapon is pulled some degrees up(dwarfs)that the weapon is strait in his hand ?

That's what I mean

I want to share my experience regarding chain classes and leather classes.

I played Leather last week

Scout/Rouge

Scout/Mage

Rouge/Priest

Rouge/Champion

Rouge/Warrior

Every rogue class except rogue/champion with katana and 2 daggers

It's like Moncef said it's very easy to do a lot of damage. Each of these classes has a good substain in trash. And the boss damage is good too.

#1 [R/W] even on the boss he was good

[R/P] - which was recently buffed a bit performs wonderfully a bit weaker than [R/W].

[R/CH] - very good in singletarget substain and burst (second class behind [R/WL] I would say. Trash is okay and has a great CC.

[R/B] - Good burst dmg slightly weaker than [R/CH] but stronger in trash substain (the speed of the group plays a decisive role here).

[S/R] - good trash substain and boss burst dmg was good for me. [R/CH] [R/W] [R/P] [R/B] others seemed a bit stronger to me overall. In summary, there is nothing wrong with the class.

[S/M] - Good substain and aoe fullburst. Okay dmg on the boss.

Okay for me.

My favourite was the [R/P] and the [R/CH]

I like the gameplay and the mechanics.

Now for chain classes

I like to play warriors almost exclusively in the ini.

In our inigroups Darkcore as an example are 2-3 scouts mostly and 1 Rouge 1-3 mpds of magecombinations like [P/S] [M/P] [M/R][M/S] [S/M] [M/WL] [M/W]<- (i will get hate for this but i think the substain is a bit too high) ps. it is not that expensive to build buff gear or the difference from 100k buffgear to 300k buffgear is not immensely high -> dmg should be higher than other mage dmg but not outreach everyone.

But let's leave that aside for now, as the topic is a different one.

In these group compositions I have some problems keeping up as a warrior, I have to push a lot and play aggressively, which doesn't rule out deaths. And even with alternating target I benefit almost 0 in the trash from bleeding with spear or katana because the mobs die in <2 seconds.

There are only 3 classes I can keep up with in our setups in 12-People Inis that is [W/S], [W/B] and [K/WL] (which I almost never play because I find it boring.

[W/Warden] is ok in trash in boss i got outdamged(overall below average)

[W/BARD] good burst trash dmg and good substain in singletarget and in fullburst boss i get caught up by the other dds (overall okay)

[W/S] the biggest advantage in our runs is the fast damage which is also comparatively high and the possibility to attack from a distance but playing the class with different weapons depending on the sitaution (spear,katana,1h,shield,2H sword) is annoying and I have to make a lot of effort to keep up.

The bleeding of the warrior, especially if you play with spear and have dealt with the scaling a bit, is strong yes, but there are not too many situations where you can make use of it, at least in our runs.

I don't think there is a need to reduce the bleeding.

Unless you design it in such a way that bleeding is completely omitted and instead buff the normal attacks of the warriors.

But 100% support the opinion of some players that bleeding should stop doing damage when the target is immune.

Warden

Warden is not that bad but way too slow in our parties in 12-People Inis. I think it can stay that way though as they are strong in not too fast parties and 6-People Inis except necro.

Champion

As a champion I can't keep up either overall in our 12-People Inis he's not bad but it's complicated and I have to work hard to get any damage at all. The best choice for champion is [CH/WRD] and [CH/R] which get weaker the faster the run is. [CH/P] could still be good, but it definitely has a singletarget problem with damage.

Buffs from Warlock

I would like to address another weak point.

As a melee fighter you get very little support from the WL in trash if he is not well trained. Only rarely a surge, soul seal, SA and wisper buff (normal trash no pulls) because the support is mostly given at the range dps. Maybe you should rethink the range of buffs.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________

I would like it if rogues do more damage when they play properly with the katana than with 2 daggers (Offhand Murk)

"nerf Rogues offhand damage (Offhand Mastery) from 48,5% to 40%"-Blackkid

would be a good solution.

[W/S] and [W/B] are good as they are I would say.

Unfortunately, the other Physical Dps warriors are not really playable in our parties.

Quote from Baboon

Yeah, warriors bleed is so over power, 24m per 2 sec while bursting - thats a lot damage.

i mean there is more possible but i agree with it. But as blackkid said bleeding should not count dmg when boss is immune like b2 rofl

Quote from Ikaria

Magma Barrier & Wanderlust are both using same absorb type. Meaning debuffs applied would be same for both bosses unless there is other conditions. Changing how absorbs work is not currently planned.

Greetings

Okay so dmg is working but the debuff from Slash as example isn't applieing on boss. Maybe it's just visual bug.??

Some people of my guild have the same problem. So it can't just be me.

just let all debuffs apply on this boss while shield this will slove all problems

It's bad that some warrior debuffs don't apply which breaks rotation soemtimes on shield boss but some other from other classes do.

I never had this problem before in coa maybe you should redesign this to the shield which tynos (last boss idk) have because there I doesn't had the problem.

I suggest to that bard/champion can use chain gear aswell

Currently it just can use leather

Since the last patch, the movement speed for players has been drastically reduced which gives me as a tank and melee dps an uncomfotable feeling and a little unfluid. i suggest for the ini shoe store to create an item called "attacker shoes" which gives 50-60% movement speed and that you do not lose the speedbuff when making and getting damage.

And for the persons wo wanna use diamonds create an itemshop item which is useable in all ini zones:)

Kind Regard Idhril