What about ch/p?
tanking without weapon is still possible and easy. If a dps would do same dmg like all other but without any weapon, it would have already been patched 
Hi,
I think a little change on ch/p is maybe needed (biggest "problem" is stamina multiplier on Light Impulse).
The stamina bonus should only be applied to the damage, if you wear any weapon.
I see something absurd in this class. Why does this class use the Katana weapon instead of the Dagger?
This is ridiculous. Now most people who play this class use katana. With this class only dagger should be used. there are combinations to use other weapons like R/Ch, R/W... I totally agree. but to replace dagger with katana is not recommended. it devalues dagger. that's a waste.
The Katana is not the problem itself. The "Perfect Slice" algorithm is the problem, which can be dodged by simple lua (for example use "Perfect Slice" every 3 seconds and you get it 90%+).
I think the buff duration (for the first short time running buffs) should be let's say 15 seconds.
The perfect slice algorithm should be any random number between 4 and 14 seconds after the first "Perfect Slice". This hit range would be much harder to just use an average value and is more usefull on manual players, who hit the "Perfect Slice". For just lua players, that can't hit it, the dagger is better than the katana
Greetings
I agree with you. Last changes are not so good. And how can warlock/mage stack 4x soul brand on boss now ? If we use Soul Seal skill in Willpower Construct mode , how are we going to stack 4x Soul brand very fast ? We must deal 4x fire damage. But this skill can be used only in Willpower Blade Mode .
You have exactly 3 Instant skills without gcd+ 1 cast for your 4 stacks. This also included 9% dark dmg. So in fact you are faster now in stacking on boss than before the patch
Display Morereducing parry to 0 yes.
But 30k damage from DC mobs not possible
I got oneshotted some days ago as k/wl and got a 600k hit. Even if threaten is up, you should get around 200-300k from attack and even more from skills of mobs.
25% would be too less compared to now more tanky rogues and warriors, which also survive 1 hit with the new dmg mitigation skills they have (sure, it's probably only for 1 hit), but 25% would be too less.
You should also get in mind, that you can play the class with pure chain gear and don't know, but you would only have 200-300k HP ?:D the massive HP for your k/wl probably comes from protector stats, that are not best in slot
You are right that full chain or even full leather are less tanky. But 300k HP with 75% damage reduction is basically 1.2kk HP (except for DoT-damage). This is fine. Then add in 8% AoE-damage reduction + Shield of Discipline + Threaten -> I am not convinced that 75% is balanced.
At least we agree on the parry to 0 part.
But exactly this is hard to balance. Different gear setups with different stats result in different HP and tankyness.
Inmy opinion the lowest HP setup should be able to run an instance. 300k HP+ 25% DMG mitigation would be in facto less than 500k HP for normal dps.
Shield of discipline goes for every class that has this skill and even threaten is Always up with knight Tanks.
Also broken is 50% perma DMG mitigation on ch/p. This class can also be played as dps. So this tanky problem is not exclusively on k/WL.
I think a minimum reduction should be 50%. In all lower cases you can say RIP chain on this class
Knight/Warlock
I might get a lot of hate for this, but this class considering its high damage is too tanky. I literally take 30k damage from Dark Core Mobs while I have 500k HP and 80% parry. With any other chainclass (yes even as Shieldform Champ) I die in 1-2hits. It is almost impossible to die with this class. Bad balancing imo.
Suggestion:
Let the conversion-skill reduce received damage by ~25% instead of 75%. Also it would just make sense if the parry gets reduced to 0 since it is being used after all to get more atkspeed and physical atk similiar to Stamina and Dex getting reduced to 0 to boost Strength.
reducing parry to 0 yes.
But 30k damage from DC mobs not possible 
I got oneshotted some days ago as k/wl and got a 600k hit. Even if threaten is up, you should get around 200-300k from attack and even more from skills of mobs.
25% would be too less compared to now more tanky rogues and warriors, which also survive 1 hit with the new dmg mitigation skills they have (sure, it's probably only for 1 hit), but 25% would be too less.
You should also get in mind, that you can play the class with pure chain gear and don't know, but you would only have 200-300k HP ?:D the massive HP for your k/wl probably comes from protector stats, that are not best in slot
As Warrior/Rogue we are talking 100% dmgloss and that is why it sucks to play this class in 80% of Dark Core raids.
always funny how ppl do math.
100% dmgloss without frenzy attack? So a warrior/rogue do 0 dmg per hit without that buff? :O That's new for me
P.S. if you write such things for balancing, think twice about such math or classes will be broken af after a push, if the responsible persons take the post as it is and don't think about it. Just a hint
I was chosen the best warrior chosen by gms on tr server
if i say something is true it is true
if i say wrong it is wrong
Abgehoben
If there is only 1 Warrior, it's not that bad XD
Btw there are some possibilities to reduce resource costs by a lot. Just saying
??? xD
You got it out of context. A nerf to 220% is not enough to justfiy if Shaodw Stab is 1 sec CD with no Global CD. My suggestions have a different Shadow Stab in mind as explained in step 1. For clarity:
Darhan suggested Shadow Stab with 1 sec CD and no Global CD.
I suggest Shadow Stab with 2 sec CD but x2 dmg, but it still has Global CD.
sure but with
Remove GCD from Keen Attack (right now this skill has Channel+GCD)
you could spam Keen Attack without GCD btw if you get a probing attack debuff from any other player (example w/k tank)
If Shadow Stab becomes 1 sec CD with no global CD, it will be too much. Even your suggested nerf For Frenzied Attack 300% to 220% is not enough.
4) Make Frenzied Attack permanent but reduce from 300% to 250%.
??? xD
Hallo,
wir suchen aktuell wieder Verstärkung. Alles ist willkommen. Einfach melden 
Siege War "Surrender Card" (ID 1248305) can be used before the time that is in the description (10-20 minutes)
Furthermore maybe it's a better solution that the enemies get rewards independent of activity score if you surrender
Comparing Rogue/Warden with Rogue/Warrior, the R/W does ~2 times more dmg than R/Wrd.
Even in single dmg the R/W is better than R/wrd.
Please adjust R/wrd a bit.
Greetings
There are people, like me, for who xbar is integrated part of the game. I have use it since my first days in 2010. Its evolving a little but literally cant play without this.
So no unchangeable changes, please.
Thanks for upload, will check tomorrow.
Yes I guess that some ppl feels like you.
Changes in general are part of every development, but their should be always solution published for the customers of the API, if such changes are implemented (in this example the list is all what was needed )
Anyway specially for you,
Addon used by minority is not reason to stop developing. Otherwise we would have stayed on original version of game as almost any progression require changes.
I mean, such changes should be shared with solutions and not only "we removed that. full stop"
what are the new possibilities to get the constant values
These strings were removed, since not used in base game anywhere. Over 12 years addons should be just updated by fans along with removing need of using such. Otherwise here is list of these strings: https://hastebin.com/share/anayupabix.makefile
Greetings
ty.
not in game does not mean nobody using it.
And btw: Never change a running system!
and not everybody is using your version 1.71 of xbar xD (the problems should be fixed by devs and/or announced in patch notes, what are the new possibilities to get the constant values, xbar was using before patch)
Hi,
regarding knight/mage I suggest to cap the mana costs of the Mana Shield to once per second and not related to the amount of hits like it is with blood Arrow
Greetings
Regarding Knight/rogue:
it is not a really viable class compared to other knights. the additional aggro AOE has a range of 50, which is really really low for a tank.
That's why I suggest to
Furthermore I would suggest to change "Leopard Instinct" (ID 495402) into 2 separate buffs. right now if you block 3 damage sources, the buff is gone completely and you don't benefit from the increased dodge. And bcs you cannot dodge skills, the buff is almost disappearing instantly, bcs nearly every single mob in the endgame instances has skills that do damage beside of normal attacks.
Greetings
Regarding Champ/Knight:
The skill "Holy Roar" (ID 1490552) should have an aggro multiplier, bcs it is only usable in shield form and as a tank kinda useless atm.
Greetings
if we use elemental catalysis we will just wait 4 minutes to use our skill again
Like all other classes? XD surprise
M/D 493528 mage can't get nature's power to get extra regeneration from this skill. I suggest that M/D doesn't need nature's power points to get extra regeneration .
Regarding patch notes when they changed it, it is intended
Hi,
I think a little change on ch/p is maybe needed (biggest "problem" is stamina multiplier on Light Impulse).
The stamina bonus should only be applied to the damage, if you wear any weapon.
Why?
bcs here (watch the 12th second):
Daily Quest Tickets in Happy Hour pls
I have a suggestion for Priest/Rogue as a healer:
A "Heal" (ID 490261) on a target should spread the "Regenerate" heal over time recover effect on 3 targets (primarily on targets, that don't have Regenerate effect).
With such change the Priest/rogue maybe is more attractive as a healer
I have a suggestion for Druid/Rogue as a healer:
If you don't have shadow pact (ID 494368) active (then you are in the healer mode), a "Recover" on a target should spread the heal over time recover effect on 2 additional targets (primarily on targets, that don't have recover effect).
With such change the Druid/rogue maybe is more attractive as a healer
